a. Salary of
$250,000.00
b. A Bonus
arrangement of a potential $20,000.00
c.
Relocation Expense reimbursement.
d. Long-term
disability (presumably through an insurer)
e. 401(k)
plan.
f. medical
insurance for the individual AND family.
As the meeting progressed, my mind kept
wandering....
What bothers me
about this arrangement ???
...and then it me like a brick
!
There were several areas that I felt
were unanswered and needed clarification before this offer be submitted to the
"chosen one".
At the conclusion of the meeting, I was
one of a few people who requested my "ticket" to make a comment in the 2 minutes
I was being allotted.
My FIRST
concern was MEDICAL
INSURANCE.
I fully agree as to the necessity of
providing a medical insurance plan to attract and retain qualified employees,
but there was one question that needed to be
clarified.
When the benefit package was announced,
the words "family coverage" were included in the
verbiage.
And so...my question to which I
received NO RESPONSE.
"Is the
association paying the cost of the GM's family in addition to the employee
premium?"
Silence was the initial response, but I
couldn't help but notice that a number of Board members were taking notes as I
proceeded with my comment in this regard.
Why was this matter
of vital concern to me?
For three reasons.
The general
business climate, the Law, and ultimate burden Sun City Anthem residents would bear !
First, let's discuss the general
business climate with these facts in mind:
1. Many of
our residents have retired from the military; and as a result, obtain V.A.
medical benefits FREE OF CHARGE.
2. A number
of our residents are retired government employees and they too, receive medical
benefits FREE OF CHARGE.
3. There are
also many residents who are retired from large corporate America and receive
some form of "subsidized" retiree medical
benefits, paying premiums far less than the actual
cost due to the retiree subsidies.
4. Many of
our residents are covered by medicare paying a minor monthly
cost...the highest of which is $145 that is
deducted from the social security check deposit for Part B coverage; and in
addition, also carry Medicare Supplements with a premium of approximately $200 each month.
Finally,
there are those of us....who have "done it ourselves" through self-employment, and pay the full
freight without any subsidy at all.
...and what these facts in my mind,
clearly demonstrate is simply....
Most people have no
idea as to the TRUE cost of medical insurance if they
must pay the premiums themselves without the availability of any subsidy to
"cushion" the true cost.
And...with these facts in mind...as a
future Self-Management independent not-for-profit
corporation...
...to provide any such benefits for
employees...THERE IS NO
SUBSIDY...
..with one exception...that "subsidy" is...
THE DUES PAYING
MEMBERS OF THE ASSOCIATION.
Now let's discuss the LAW....and...The Affordable Care
Act provisions which become effective as of January 1,
2016.
Prior to that date, only employees
considered "full-time"... those working 30 or more hours per week, were
considered eligible for group medical benefits...
...and as such, they had the ability to opt out of coverage DUE TO AN EMPLOYEE in
most of the cases, being asked to "share" in the
premium cost.
This is still the case...but...we have
something called "discrimination laws" that must be
adhered in allowing corporations to establish benefit plans on behalf of their
employees.
...and herein lies the conflict in
providing "family coverage" to the new General
Manager of Sun City Anthem.
If Sun City Anthem
pays 100% of the cost for that
individual, it must also pay 100% of the cost for ALL
OTHER full-time workers. Hence NO ONE WOULD OPT
OUT...and association costs would increase.
But...there's
more...
Obamacare
has entered the equation and under certain conditions (and in my belief,
applies to Sun City Anthem)...
If Sun City Anthem
pays 100% of the cost for dependents for one particular individual (the General
Manager), it must also pay 100% of the cost not only for the dependents of
full-time employees but THOSE HAVING DEPENDENTS WE
UTILIZE FOR INDEPENDENT CONTRACTING SERVICES as
well.
Let me use a CONSERVATIVE
example...
...I use the word "conservative"
because most people are unaware that the cost of DEPENDENT COVERAGE ONLY for an individual under age 65, now
exceeds $1,000 a month or
more.
Finally, how does this affect the property owners of Sun City Anthem ?
Just considering DEPENDENT COVERAGE ALONE....NOT
INCLUDING THE EMPLOYEE COST...
..If the association pays the full cost
of the dependent for the GM's dependent coverage alone, and if we have 150 "eligible"
(employees or contractors) with families under age 65, for dependent coverage ONLY, that would mean a monthly cost
of:
$150,000
Annually
$1,800,000
...and that startling
figure amounts to approximately...
23%
...of the gross annual
dues revenue !
And
if premiums rise a minimal 5% after the first
year?
This percentage
increase would add an additional annual cost of ...
$90,000
...which when added to
the above 23%, would effectively increase that percentage
to...
24%
...of gross annual dues
revenue !
In
addition...
Payment of 100% of the GM's EMPLOYEE COVERAGE would further
trigger requiring 100% of all employees and contractor individual costs to be
paid at 100% as well...and based on a MININMAL COST of $300 per month per
covered employee or contractor (with 150 eligible
individuals)...
...further INCREASES the monthly
expenditure ...
$45,000...
$540,000
Annually
Totaling
$2,340,000
almost 30%
of gross annual dues
revenue
Adding the minimal 5% increase the following year,
brings the total
to
$2,520,000
32%
of gross annual dues
revenue
Does this shock you? If these estimates alone don't convince you this is impending
disaster...
Based on the above
assumptions and a 5% increase in rate structure, that would mean that of your
total...
$1,100.00
of current annual
dues...
$352.74
...would be applied to
medical insurance ALONE.
Would our financial
future be capable of sustaining a dues structure without having to increase
the assessments?
We
are convinced that would be impossible...that to increase our budgeted
expenses 24%....increasing each year...for this one item alone...
...would create financial catastrophe for
our community!
Accordingly, we believe
that is very idea CEASE IMMEDIATELY before a salary/benefit package including the FULL payment of
employee and dependent medical insurance premiums be offered to that
individual...
...that a cost sharing formula EXIST for
both employee and dependent premiums for the sake of the FINANCIAL HEALTH
of the Sun City Anthem.
It's time we get VOCAL...the typical resident will not do anything until the monthly maintenance goes through the roof (and then they'll only complain).
I had wanted to attend the recent meeting but my knee surgery prevented it.
It is time that ALL of us attend these meetings (I have this vision from the old 'Frankenstein' movie where the villagers (with flaming torches) are yelling "Kill the Monster" !
I may sound totally paranoid and cynical, but that's what I get for living in the NY/NJ region for 60 years.